the latest regional New Jersey high school sports news

Home
Football
Feature Articles
Page 2
Scoreboard
Video Feed
The Buzz
Links
Archive
Contact Us

Bring the beauty, economy and healthful benefits of the sun into your home with daylight harvesters and solar powered fans.

Insist on the Original - Solar Illuminations is your local certified dealer & installer.

visit www.solar-illuminations.com

call 973-228-6504

Montclair coach Butch Fortunato was ecstatic after his Mounties roared from behind to edge Passaic, 14-13, in 1982 Thanksgiving Day game at Woodman Field, and Rutherford, with, from left, the head coach Andy Howell, QB Kyle Russell (7) and assistant Steve Dunn were more than happy to see 2017 season end with a sectional tate playoff title. (SC photo and courtesy of Brian Carr)

Group Finals Seem Here To Stay
But Do We Need Them In NJ?

By Steve Tober
for sidelinehatter.com

Blame it all on USA Today.

When the newspaper debuted in 1982 there was some of the initial exposure to national scholastic rankings and the coaches here in New Jersey could look and see how by late November or early December teams from states such as California, Florida and Texas had played 14-15 games after playing down to an overall state champion.

It was a time when the sectional playoffs were still taking off in the Garden State after commencing with an abbreviated format in 1974 and gradually expanding all the way to the current format of playing down to 7 group champions since 2022.

But, has it been worth the expansion of steps in the playoff process to create those group champs?

In conjunction with the modern-day, long-winded Jersey high school football season, ‘official’ practice commences in early or mid-August; however, teams have already been gathering for nearly two months for either near-daily meetings and workouts beyond the regular weight room sessions and those inevitable 7-on-7’s which start almost immediately following spring sports’ state finals and whose importance in the overall scheme of things can be debated ad nauseum.  

Back before the playoffs coaches might even apologize for starting pre-season practice on Labor Day weekend. Now, the so-called ‘Week Zero’ games start things off in late August a week before the holiday weekend to bid adieu to the unofficial summer season.

Playing down to a state sectional champion which preceded the move to ‘regional’ champions in 2019 seemed to work best on the Garden State gridiron scene while still leaving room for those dwindling number of Thanksgiving Day rivalries which have unfortunately disintegrated to just a couple of handfuls in today’s world.

Turkey Day contests used to still be important to playoff finalists. Back in 1982, an 8-1 Montclair team headed to a North 2, Group 4 playoff championship game against Union a week and a half after its Thanksgiving game vs. Passaic, enjoyed one of its best-ever Turkey Day victories against the Craig ‘Ironhead’ Heyward-led Passaic Indians, overcoming a 13-0 fourth quarter deficit to win, 14-13, on a pair of TD runs by James ‘Boo’ Overbey and successful extra point placements by kicker Ben Brennan, before a crowd of 4,000 people at historic Woodman Field.

Yes, there used to be up to 10,000 people at Woodman for games back in the 1950s or ‘60s, but even half of that in the early 1980s is a far better crowd number than what is seen in most places today.

Even some of the group state finals at either Rutgers or MetLife Stadium fail to generate more than a few thousand fans in vast empty-looking buildings.
Passaic was not even a traditional holiday rival for Montclair; however, with the interruption of the Mounties’ longtime Thanksgiving Day rivalry with neighboring Bloomfield when the Bengals became members of the Northern New Jersey Interscholastic League in 1976, the team moved first to play another Essex neighbor Nutley on Turkey Day for five years (1977-81) before a 10-year series with Passaic.

As far as the importance of the 1982 Thanksgiving Day comeback victory against Ironhead and Co., all one had to see was the expression on the face of Mounties head coach Butch Fortunato (see photo near top of page).

Butch, who would not be shy about arguing a call for his team or engaging in a spirited discussion with an official, was not one to show much emotion when it came to generating a smile or celebrating a win.

He was visibly extremely happy with his team’s 1982 comeback win vs. Passaic.

Which brings us back to the assertion that teams do not need a group state final to feel fulfilled as a player or coach.   

The season should once again end with sectional finals on the first weekend in December.

I agree with my longtime sports-writing colleague Joe Hofmann now of Big State Sports, who says that we should no longer have playoff championships at either MetLife or Rutgers and return the games to home fields for finals, and that means group finals in the current state of things which doesn’t appear to be ending any time soon with the proverbial toothpaste-already-out-of-the-tube situation that some coaches – but not all – campaigned and urged a vote for.

One of those perfectly happy with the format of playing down to a sectional champion as the final stage is Rutherford’s Steve Dunn, the successful fifth-year head coach who guided the Bulldogs to a 9-2 record this fall.

He was an assistant coach for the 2017 Rutherford team which finished 11-0 and captured a N2G2 playoff crown.

“I couldn’t care less that Newton won the other section (North 1, Group 2),” said Dunn. “To us we were champions of world and everyone associated with our Rutherford team called us state champs!

“We didn’t care who won the South 2 title either. Maybe I’m more of a traditionalist, but the sectional title is a great way to end the season and the community really comes together for that championship game.

“I also don’t like the fact that today many teams see their season end around Halloween in late October.” 

While many sectional finals had previously been played at MetLife Stadium, including that 2019 N2G2 final involving the Rutherford team, nothing beats playing a championship game at one’s home high school field.   

Remember the Randolph-Montclair North 2, Group 4 championship game in 1990, called ‘The Game of the Century’ by some? There were 10,000 people at Woodman Field that afternoon and two TV stations (Suburban Cable, TV-3 and Sammons Cable of Morris County) televising the contest which nj.com touted was a monumental occasion and their reporter Matt Stanmyre did a documentary video about the players and coaches involved in the historic game.

No matter how many times we’ve been told that the players simply love running out of the tunnel at MetLife Stadium, one’s home high school field is still the ideal place to draw the entire community together for a championship weekend game.

And whether it was Foley Field or Woodman Field back in the heyday of the Montclair-Bloomfield Thanksgiving Day series, or the still-surviving ancient rivalries of Millville-Vineland or Phillipsburg-Easton there is also a lastting spot in Jersey high school football lore for the Turkey Day tradition which is now almost a forgotten jewel that should be forever treasured.                  

Follow JR Parachini on 'X' @parachini_jr 

Thanksgiving Day rivalry diehards like Dale Berra of Montclair and TK Tripucka of Bloomfield will forever relish the memories of past Mountie-Bengal Turkey Day clashes. (SC photo and courtesy of Anthony Sorce)

copyright 2005 Sideline Chatter - to comment contact the webmaster